Daily Archives: November 10, 2026

Case 001178

Error and/or relief

On resentencing under section 1172.75, the trial court erred in not determining whether the gang enhancements met the requirements of AB 333, which amended the elements required for the enhancements since they were originally imposed.

First Holding:

AB 333 changed what the prosecution must prove to establish a gang enhancement. As relevant here, it narrowed the definition of a criminal street gang, required that any pattern of criminal activity be one the gang’s members collectively engage in, and required that the offense have commonly benefited the gang in a way that is more than reputational. The jury that found the gang enhancements true more than 20 years ago was not instructed on these requirements because they did not yet exist.

Authority:

PEN 186.22

People v. Clark (2024) 15 Cal.5th 743, 761–762 [describing the organizational nexus the amended statute requires]

Second Holding:

The amendments apply to the defendant. A recall and resentencing under section 1172.75 reopens the judgment, and a sentence that has been reopened is not final for purposes of In re Estrada. A case in which an appellate court has affirmed the conviction and remanded for reconsideration of sentencing-related issues is not final and that ameliorative legislation therefore applies. A remand is required.

Authority:

In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740

People v. Lopez (2025) 17 Cal.5th 388, 392-393

Third Holding:

There remains the question of remedy. In our discretion, in the appropriate case, we can determine whether the erroneous imposition of a gang enhancement was harmless based on the appellate record. But here, unlike in Cooper, no reporter’s transcript of the trial has been prepared, and the trial evidence is not available to us. Accordingly, the trial court is better positioned to develop that record and to assess harmlessness against it.

Authority:

People v. Tran (2022) 13 Cal.5th 1169, 1207 [omission of an element added by intervening law requires reversal unless it appears beyond a reasonable doubt that the verdict would have been the same]

People v. Cooper (2023) 14 Cal.5th 735, 743–747

Fourth Holding:

We do not shift the burden the law assigns. The burden of establishing that the omission of a correct jury instruction was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt rests with the People, as the beneficiaries of the error, and it remains with them on remand.

Authority:

People v. Cutting (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th 344, 349

Case 001177

Error and/or relief

The minute order and the abstract of judgment must be corrected to reflect that the court waived the restitution fine, the parole revocation restitution fine, and the special assessment fees.

Holding:

The minute order and the abstract of judgment must be corrected to reflect that the court waived the fines and fees it they reflect.

(Gary note: The court cited no authority for its order to correct the minute order and abstract of judgment. I have listed some of the cases the court could have drawn from.

(I do recognize that it might seem silly to continue to summarize such cases, but in my opinion, the scale of incorrect abstracts of judgment is high enough that I feel it is important to continue to urge counsel to somehow review the abstracts of judgment. While in this case, the total waived fees amounted to less than $500 (plus the parole restitution fine), some abstracts list amounts as high as $10,000 despite the court having waived the restitution fine.

(And many abstracts that I have included in the summaries contain very serious errors on the length of sentence imposed–some reflecting life sentences rather than a far shorter determinate term. Some short the defendant thousands of days in credit for time served. Occasionally I have run across an abstract that understated the sentence in some respect, but there are far fewer of those.

(The abstract of judgment and the sentencing minute order are what the custodial officials rely on for setting release dates, parole eligibility dates, and amounts of fines and fees that must be withheld from prisoner wages or funds placed in their accounts by friends and family. It seems to me that it is important that they be correct.)

Authority:

People v. Mitchell (2001) 26 Cal.4th 181, 185

People v. Delgado (2008) 43 Cal.4th 1059, 1070

People v. Leon (2020) 8 Cal.5th 831, 855

In re Black (1967) 66 Cal.2d 881, 890

People v. Zackery (2007) 147 Cal.App.4th 380, 385

People v. Farell (2002) 28 Cal.4th 381, 384, fn. 2

Case 001176

Error and/or relief

This was a writ of habeas corpus to permit the defendant to rely on the In re Benoit principle of constructive timely filing of a notice of appeal. The petition was granted, and the defendant was allowed to proceed with his appeal.

First Holding:

Petitioner seeks permission to file a belated notice of appeal under the doctrine of constructive filing. The People have voiced no opposition. Granted.

Authority:

In re Benoit (1973) 10 Cal.3d 72

Second Holding (Gary Musings, which is nearly identical to what I wrote in Case 001149):

GARY NOTE: the second, third, fourth, fifth, and sixth holdings and their authorities are provided by me and did not appear in the opinion, but are important enough to mention in the context of the filing of a notice of appeal.

What I have set forth in this summary is virtually a direct copy-and-paste from my summaries in Case 001149 and Case 000229. The summary for Case 000085 contains a more thorough discussion of the Benoit rule regarding what would otherwise be untimely filings of the notice of appeal.

Where a defendant is incarcerated and has requested his attorney to file a notice of appeal within the time to file a notice, the court may deem the otherwise late notice of appeal to have been constructively filed timely. The Attorney General’s concession on behalf of the People is deemed to constitute an agreement that the requested relief ought to be granted without further proceedings

Authority:

In re Benoit (1973) 10 Cal.3d 72, 81–82

People v. Romero (1994) 8 Cal.4th 728, 740, fn. 7

Third Holding:

In felony cases, a notice of appeal and any statement required by Penal Code section 1237.5 must be filed within 60 days after the rendition of the judgment or the making of the order being appealed. Except as provided in rule 8.66 [which deals with when catastrophes happen], no court may extend the time to file a notice of appeal.

Authority:

Rules of Court, rule 8.308

Fourth Holding:

In misdemeanor cases, the notice of appeal under this article must be filed within 30 days after the rendition of the judgment or the making of the order being appealed.

Authority:

Rules of Court, rule 8.393

Fifth Holding:

As used in rule 8.304(a)(1) regarding the filing of a notice of appeal in the superior court in a felony case, “felony case” means any criminal action in which a felony is charged, regardless of the outcome. A felony is “charged” when an information or indictment accusing the defendant of a felony is filed or a complaint accusing the defendant of a felony is certified to the superior court under Penal Code section 859a.

A felony case includes an action in which the defendant is charged with: (A) A felony and a misdemeanor or infraction, but is convicted of only the misdemeanor or infraction; (B) A felony, but is convicted of only a lesser offense; or (C) An offense filed as a felony but punishable as either a felony or a misdemeanor, and the offense is thereafter deemed a misdemeanor under Penal Code section 17(b).

Authority:

Rules of Court, rule 8.304(a)(2)

Sixth Holding:

An untimely notice of appeal divests the appellate court of jurisdiction to hear the appeal.

Authority:

In re G.C. (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1119

People v. Mendez (1999) 19 Cal.4th 1084, 1094 [An untimely notice of appeal is wholly ineffectual. The delay cannot be waived, it cannot be cured by nunc pro tunc order, and the appellate court has no power to give relief, but must dismiss the appeal on motion or on its own motion.]

Case 001175

Error and/or relief

On resentencing under section 1172.75, the court should have vacated the restitution fine, which was imposed more than 10 years earlier.

Holding:

Effective January 1, 2025, AAB 1186 (2023–2024 Reg. Sess.) modified section 1465.9. Section 1465.9(d) now provides, in pertinent part, that upon the expiration of 10 years after the date of imposition of a restitution fine pursuant to Section 1202.4, the balance, including any collection fees, shall be unenforceable and uncollectible and any portion of a judgment imposing those fines shall be vacated. There is no language in section 1465.9 limiting its relief in cases of resentencing.

As the application of amended section 1465.9 involves statutory construction, it is subject to de novo review.

Authority:

People v. Greeley (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 609, 626 [holding that analogous language in section 1465.9(a) mandates vacation of a portion of a judgment for the purpose of striking the unpaid balance of the relevant assessment]

Case 001174

Error and/or relief

It was error for the court to impose sentence for the great bodily injury enhancement on the count alleging battery causing serious bodily injury. We reverse and remand for further sentencing proceedings.

First Holding:

Section 12022.7(a) generally provides sentence enhancements for crimes resulting in infliction of great bodily injury. However, an enhancement shall not be imposed if infliction of great bodily injury is an element of the offense.

Authority:

PEN 12022.7(g)

Second Holding:

Great bodily injury in section 12022.7 and serious bodily injury in the offense of battery causing serious bodily injury are essentially equivalent elements. Great bodily injury is therefore an element of battery causing serious bodily injury. The trial court accordingly should not have imposed the section 12022.7 enhancement.

Authority:

In re Cabrera (2023) 14 Cal.5th 476, 490

People v. Hawkins (1993) 15 Cal.App.4th 1373, 1375 [the terms have substantially the same meaning]

Third Holding:

When part of a sentence is stricken on review, remand for a full resentencing on all counts is appropriate to allow the trial court to exercise its sentencing discretion in light of the changed circumstances.

Authority:

People v. Buycks (2018) 5 Cal.5th 857, 893