Case 001202

Error and/or relief

It was error to impose five-year enhancements under section 667.6(a) for each of the defendant’s prior convictions, because the defendant’s conviction was not for a listed offense that triggers the enhancements. Further, the abstract of judgment and the minute order must be corrected.

First Holding:

A person who is convicted of an offense specified in section 667.6(e) and who has been convicted previously of any of those offenses shall receive a five-year enhancement for each of those prior convictions. Subdivision (e) of section 667.6 lists section 288, subdivision (b), but not section 288, subdivision (a), the offense for which the defendant was convicted. The true findings on those allegations should therefore be stricken.

Authority:

PEN 667.6(a), (e)

Second Holding:

The trial court found true enhancement allegations under section 651(a), and then struck those enhancements. They appear, however, on the abstract of judgment and in the sentencing minute order, with a notation that they were stricken.

The directions on the abstract of judgment state, “Do not list any stricken enhancement(s)” and “Do not list enhancements fully stricken by the court.” to the extent the minute order and abstract of judgment reflect the imposition of the enhancements and the striking or staying of their associated punishments, they diverge from the trial court’s oral pronouncement, and the oral pronouncement prevails.

We will therefore direct the trial court to correct the abstract of judgment and the corresponding minute order.

Authority:

People v. Leon (2020) 8 Cal.5th 831, 855