Error and/or relief
After initially stating that it would impose a firearm enhancement pursuant to section 12022.53(d), on the defendant’s sentence on count 1, the trial court later struck the punishment on that enhancement. The abstract of judgment in this case fails to accurately reflect this aspect of the defendant’s sentence, listing the enhancement and time imposed of “25 years” without any indication that punishment was stricken. As a result, we will order the abstract of judgment corrected to reflect the trial court’s actual pronouncement of sentence in this case.
(Gary musing: On my soapbox again–the abstract of judgment indicates that an enhancement was imposed to add 25 years to the defendant’s sentence. Yet the trial court actually struck that enhancement. How lucky is it that the defendant filed a notice of appeal and that appellate counsel or the appellate court noticed the error? Would the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation have discovered the error? Would it have discovered the error and sought correction in time to determine the nature of housing the defendant was to be assigned (assuming that length of sentence is a criterion)? Yet one more example in support of my quest to encourage trial counsel to obtain and review abstracts of judgment.
(As I pointed out recently in an earlier post–my statistics over the past year reflect that roughly 1 in 14 criminal appeals has an error in the abstract of judgment or sentencing minute order that paints a plight worse than imposed on the defendant. Roughly 7%. Dismounting the soapbox now.)
Holding:
Courts may correct clerical errors at any time, and appellate courts … that have properly assumed jurisdiction of cases have ordered correction of abstracts of judgment that did not accurately reflect the oral judgments of sentencing courts. Where there is an evident discrepancy between the abstract of judgment and the judgment that the reporter’s transcript reflect, the appellate court itself should order the trial court to correct the abstract of judgment.
Authority:
People v. Mitchell (2001) 26 Cal.4th 181, 185, 188

