Case 001178

Error and/or relief

On resentencing under section 1172.75, the trial court erred in not determining whether the gang enhancements met the requirements of AB 333, which amended the elements required for the enhancements since they were originally imposed.

First Holding:

AB 333 changed what the prosecution must prove to establish a gang enhancement. As relevant here, it narrowed the definition of a criminal street gang, required that any pattern of criminal activity be one the gang’s members collectively engage in, and required that the offense have commonly benefited the gang in a way that is more than reputational. The jury that found the gang enhancements true more than 20 years ago was not instructed on these requirements because they did not yet exist.

Authority:

PEN 186.22

People v. Clark (2024) 15 Cal.5th 743, 761–762 [describing the organizational nexus the amended statute requires]

Second Holding:

The amendments apply to the defendant. A recall and resentencing under section 1172.75 reopens the judgment, and a sentence that has been reopened is not final for purposes of In re Estrada. A case in which an appellate court has affirmed the conviction and remanded for reconsideration of sentencing-related issues is not final and that ameliorative legislation therefore applies. A remand is required.

Authority:

In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740

People v. Lopez (2025) 17 Cal.5th 388, 392-393

Third Holding:

There remains the question of remedy. In our discretion, in the appropriate case, we can determine whether the erroneous imposition of a gang enhancement was harmless based on the appellate record. But here, unlike in Cooper, no reporter’s transcript of the trial has been prepared, and the trial evidence is not available to us. Accordingly, the trial court is better positioned to develop that record and to assess harmlessness against it.

Authority:

People v. Tran (2022) 13 Cal.5th 1169, 1207 [omission of an element added by intervening law requires reversal unless it appears beyond a reasonable doubt that the verdict would have been the same]

People v. Cooper (2023) 14 Cal.5th 735, 743–747

Fourth Holding:

We do not shift the burden the law assigns. The burden of establishing that the omission of a correct jury instruction was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt rests with the People, as the beneficiaries of the error, and it remains with them on remand.

Authority:

People v. Cutting (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th 344, 349