Error and/or relief
The abstract of judgment must be by using the correct form for an indeterminate sentence.
(Gary musings: As a regular reader might recognize, I have expressed many times that there are abstracts of judgment with significant errors, and that counsel should somehow arrange to check them for accuracy. Most of the time, the errors represent a plight worse than the defendant was exposed to by the oral pronouncement. Getting those abstracts corrected will result in some relief for the defendant, whether in the case it represents or in a future case whose disposition takes your case into consideration.
(This case, however, is one of those where the abstract incorrectly reflected a determinate sentence of 27 years rather than an indeterminate sentence of 27 years to life. It thus is not a victory in the sense of a case where the court afforded some relief to the defendant.
(But I do feel it is important for my summaries blog to report errors in the abstracts of judgment regardless of whether the defendant benefits by the correction, if for no other reason than to show how often abstracts or minutes contain material errors.
(As I draft this summary, I can see that I have “tagged” abstract errors in 22.5% of the more than 1,100 summaries I have posted. As I have said elsewhere, I normally post summaries of only those cases with at least a minor benefit granted to the defendant. But the number that I have tagged as having errors in the abstracts or minutes, represents 7% of ALL unpublished cases issued since the middle of November 2025 where the caption is “P. v.,” which is the caption used for criminal appeals on the opinion source site.
(Assuming that more than 3,600 “P. v.” cases is a representative sample over nearly a year’s time, one in fourteen abstracts of judgments in felony criminal cases that have filed a notice of appeal will have an error, most likely an error that penalizes the defendant worse than the court’s oral pronouncement.
(And mind you, people don’t file notices of appeal because they discovered the abstract of judgment contains errors. Those discrepancies are discovered when appellate counsel or the appellate court reviews the record on appeal. But the appeal was generated for some reason other than errors in the abstract. Because it’s a simple matter for trial counsel to bring an error to the attention of the clerk or the court to get a correction. Assuming the error was noticed, it would be easy to fix without having to file a notice of appeal. I have never seen an appeal brought because there was a dispute over an error in the abstract. I think it is a reasonable conclusion that roughly 7% of all abstracts in criminal cases–whether or not appealed–likely contain errors in the abstracts or sentencing minutes.
(Hence, my encouragement to you to follow up on your client’s case to make sure the abstract does not reflect a three strikes sentence where your client was sentenced to a determinate term. Or a $10,000 restitution fine that was actually waived by the judge. Or significantly fewer days credit for time served than the client was awarded. Or a recitation that suggests the felony was a serious felony that might be used to enhance or trigger alternative sentencing schemes in future cases when, in fact, the felony of conviction was NOT a serious felony. Etc.
(Dismounting from my soapbox now. Have a good day.)
First Holding:
The abstract of judgment filed in this case was on form CR-290.1, “Felony Abstract of Judgment—Determinate Single, Concurrent, or Full-Term Consecutive Count Form,” but a determinate term was not imposed in this case. The trial court did not use form CR-292, “Abstract of Judgment—Prison Commitment—Indeterminate.” And it does not correctly reflect the indeterminate sentence that was imposed.
Authority:
People v. Magana (2021) 63 Cal.App.5th 1120, 1122 (Gary note: Magana was cited by the court, but it merely reflects a recognition of the two types of abstracts of judgment in a case where there were errors in the abstract)
Second Holding:
Courts may correct clerical errors at any time, and appellate courts that have properly assumed jurisdiction of cases have ordered correction of abstracts of judgment that did not accurately reflect the oral judgments of sentencing courts. We thus direct the trial court to file a corrected abstract of judgment showing that defendant was sentenced to the indeterminate term of 27 years to life for count 1, and not a determinate term of 27 years.
Authority:
People v. Mitchell (2001) 26 Cal.4th 181, 185, 188
People v. Saavedra (2018) 24 Cal.App.5th 605, 616

